※ 本文為 JackLee5566.bbs. 轉寄自 ptt.cc 更新時間: 2017-01-14 14:23:49
看板 NBA
作者 標題 [外絮] 各名宿心目中的GOAT
時間 Sat Jan 14 12:47:35 2017
原始文章出處 : http://tinyurl.com/zsgn8ga
偶然看到這篇一年多前的文章.
我們在網上搜到的GOAT 大多數都是球迷票選, 球評票選或新聞網自己選的.
很少有去整理各名宿心目中的GOAT,
作者很貼心的附上影片連結或原始報導出處.
內文太長我就不全翻了, 以下就名單列出來跟補一下(括弧)我所知道的更新或錯誤.
1.) Michael Jordan – Himself (Jordan)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lTMf_UHxdY0
(作者扭曲了意思, MJ影片一開始就說GOAT是個愚蠢話題,
影片裡頭他比較的是最偉大的冠軍, 而非GOAT.
MJ有過多次對外發言認為不同時代的球員無法同時競爭,
GOAT在任何人身上都不適用.)
2.) Bird – Probably Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/jx5wsx3
1985年: Bird 比喻MJ為有史以來最強的新秀
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
http://tinyurl.com/juv445q
NBA: 10 questions with Larry Bird | Sports | GMA News Online
After avoiding questions since his arrival in Manila, Monday, Celtics legend and Indiana Pacers president of basketball operations Larry Bird finally ...
![[圖]](http://images.gmanews.tv/v3/webpics/v3/2013/10/2013_10_09_16_08_41.jpg)
3.) Magic Johnson – Jordan
https://youtu.be/u69SCU79_O0
Is Michael Jordan The Greatest Ever? Magic Johnson, Charles Barkley, Danny Ainge, Kenny Smith... - YouTube A Jordan analysis by a couple of NBA greats and Kenny Smith. Is Jordan the greatest of all time? As someone who saw him play, not even at his prime, because ...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0bba2/0bba265bb8436287a225ddaa7cd2bcd112ff07f5" alt=""
4.) Bill Russell – Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
5.) Oscar Robertson - 沒選
http://tinyurl.com/zj5ld65
Oscar Robertson: Jordan is not greatest ever | NBA | Sporting News
Sure, Michael Jordan was a great player, but the greatest ever? Not so, says Oscar Robertson. ...
![[圖]](http://st.snimg.com/image/logo/sn-social.png)
Does not think Jordan was the greatest.
6.) Kareem Abdul-Jabbar - 沒選
http://tinyurl.com/jz5c4zb
Kareem says Oscar Robertson better than Jordan or LeBron | ProBasketballTalk
While most current NBA fans give Michael Jordan the nod in the hypothetical “best player ever” competition, but a lot of that is simply due to timing ...
![[圖]](https://nbcprobasketballtalk.files.wordpress.com/2012/08/0826-oscar-robertson-608.jpg)
大O > MJ 和 LBJ
張伯倫 = 歷史最佳得分手
7.) Isiah Thomas – Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
http://tinyurl.com/zz2rmze
最近變成了Jabbar.
MJ主宰了90年代, 但是80才是黃金時代, Jabbar同時主宰了70跟80.
8.) Karl Malone – Wilt Chamberlain.
http://tinyurl.com/hc6t53f
MJ not Malone's pick for all-time best - Chicago Bulls Blog- ESPN
Karl Malone didn't pick Michael Jordan as his greatest all-time player. ...
![[圖]](http://a4.espncdn.com/combiner/i?img=%2Fphoto%2F2012%2F0613%2Fchi_u_mjkm_cr_300.jpg)
9.) John Stockton - 沒選
https://youtu.be/ZlWnTo5ca3o
ESPN First Take | John Stockton COMPARES LeBron James to Michael Jordan - YouTube Stephen A. Smith, Skip Bayless and John Stockton discuss the current state of the NBA aswell as express their opinions on Derrick Rose and Michael Jordan vs ...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4da13/4da132bdc653cf9b71a8346504645cca3afc6c06" alt=""
10.) Charles Barkley – Jordan
唯一同時是得分跟防守端的王者.
https://youtu.be/u69SCU79_O0
Is Michael Jordan The Greatest Ever? Magic Johnson, Charles Barkley, Danny Ainge, Kenny Smith... - YouTube A Jordan analysis by a couple of NBA greats and Kenny Smith. Is Jordan the greatest of all time? As someone who saw him play, not even at his prime, because ...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0bba2/0bba265bb8436287a225ddaa7cd2bcd112ff07f5" alt=""
11.) Elgin Baylor – Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
12.) Bob Cousy – Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
我跳起來最高只到藍下, 他跳起來最高點已經飛在籃板上了.
13.) Shaquille O’Neal – Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
(最近幾年改口認為GOAT是Dr. J
http://tinyurl.com/hzp9gu4 )
Shaquille O’Neal thinks Julius Erving was the greatest basketball player ever | For The Win Exciting? Yes. Greatest ever? No. ...
14.) Julius Erving, Dr. J – Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
https://youtu.be/JJn5MEZ_zUg
15.) Jerry West – Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
他是現代的Babe Ruth.
16.) Scottie Pippen – Jordan
http://tinyurl.com/68hllae
17.) Bill Walton – Kareem Abdul Jabbar
http://tinyurl.com/gu4onwm
他是我對位過的最強球員.
Jabbar > Magic, Bird , Jordan.
他是我前進的動力, 但無論我作出多少努力, 他都會在我面前得50分.
又會傳球又會得分又會防守.
18.) Hakeem Olajuwon – Probably Jordan.
http://tinyurl.com/h5clxgg
LBJ是最偉大之一, 但是 MJ > LBJ.
19.) Bob Pettit – Bill Russell
http://tinyurl.com/gqjjke5
The Q&A: At 80, Pettit Reflects On Wilt, Russell, Cousy And Life Outside The NBA « NBA.com | Hang Time Blog Bob Pettit wasn't sure what to call this date: Dec. 12, 2012. Take the short version – 12/12/12 – and it looks like a triple-double. Or a triple-dozen ...
他有最強的得勝慾望, 他的防守太可怕了.
人們都說他是所有人生勝利組中的人生勝利組,
那不如就改稱他為GOAT吧. 因為打球就是要勝利.
20.) George Gervin – Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
沒來源, 但是作者看過影片
21.) Ricky Barry – Maybe Wilt Chamberlain.
http://tinyurl.com/gwvc4l3
CNN/SI - Michael Jordan Retires - Praise from his peers - Monday February 01, 1999 03:52 PM Most of the 50 greatest players in NBA history agree that MJ stands alone, the best to ever step on the court ...
大家都說他是GOAT. 但是不同位置無法比較, 他是我見過的最佳雙能衛.
http://tinyurl.com/hg46f8l
Barry: PED’s Wouldn’t Be That Helpful In Basketball « CBS Pittsburgh
Basketball Hall of Famer Rick Barry talked about PED use in pro sports with Starkey, Miller and Mueller. ...
![[圖]](https://cbspittsburgh.files.wordpress.com/2013/02/rick-barry.jpg?w=420)
他是有史以來最棒的大個子球員. 有了大個子, 你就能奪得勝利.
22.) Walt Frazier – Wilt Chamberlain
http://tinyurl.com/gwkhnbw
Walt Frazier says Wilt Chamberlain is GOAT | ProBasketballTalk
Jordan is not on the top of his list. ...
23.) Wilt Chamberlain – Meadowlark Lemon (哈林籃球隊傳奇)
http://tinyurl.com/y9um4nj
Meadowlark Lemon > Dr. J 和 MJ
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 115.164.191.247
※ 文章代碼(AID): #1OUQrmd- (NBA)
※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/NBA/M.1484369264.A.9FE.html
推 : 那些不選喬丹的人其實仔細看看都有充分的理由1F 01/14 12:49
推 : 大帥的答案真特別2F 01/14 12:49
推 : Jordan第一,Jabbar第二基本上是板上釘釘的事了3F 01/14 12:50
→ : 像跟大帥同時代一起競爭的貝瑞就不太會選喬丹,畢4F 01/14 12:50
→ : 竟有無親自交手是挺關鍵的,可以反映數字上看不到
→ : 的實力
→ : 天鉤獎項史上第三多,可是以一哥身分帶隊的冠軍就只
→ : 有71跟80那兩個
→ : 82那冠軍看不太出是他還是魔術當球隊一哥
→ : 所以天鉤的第二其實也沒那麼穩,但最差也是第三,多
→ : 輸給羅素這樣子。
→ : 竟有無親自交手是挺關鍵的,可以反映數字上看不到
→ : 的實力
→ : 天鉤獎項史上第三多,可是以一哥身分帶隊的冠軍就只
→ : 有71跟80那兩個
→ : 82那冠軍看不太出是他還是魔術當球隊一哥
→ : 所以天鉤的第二其實也沒那麼穩,但最差也是第三,多
→ : 輸給羅素這樣子。
推 : 看到himself 笑了 XDDDDDDDD 霸氣12F 01/14 12:59
推 : 大帥其實這樣不意外 他本身在哈林打過不短的時間13F 01/14 13:04
→ : 甚至有時候休賽期也會去打哈林
→ : 甚至有時候休賽期也會去打哈林
→ : MJ,天勾,羅素,張大帥,名宿的歷史前4。15F 01/14 13:04
推 : 老喬跟賈霸蠻多的16F 01/14 13:05
推 : 樓上這四大 完全不能反駁 要反駁的來戰17F 01/14 13:05
推 : Green、Rodman、Worldpeace、Barkley 不服來戰18F 01/14 13:08
推 : 沒Kobe19F 01/14 13:12
→ : 很明顯 Jordna前輩不選他的比較多一點20F 01/14 13:15
推 : MJ猛 其他三個都中鋒21F 01/14 13:16
→ : 不過能讓 Bird 服氣也不容易22F 01/14 13:16
推 : 答案幾乎都是張伯倫 賈霸 MJ23F 01/14 13:16
推 : 竟然沒有KOBE24F 01/14 13:18
→ : 這名單很明顯和各人活躍年代以及對位過對手的不同25F 01/14 13:19
→ : 有非常高度的相關 這是絕大多數人的思考模式 倒不是
→ : 說選A不選B就一定非常認真比較過覺得A比B強之類的
→ : 有非常高度的相關 這是絕大多數人的思考模式 倒不是
→ : 說選A不選B就一定非常認真比較過覺得A比B強之類的
推 : 大帥怎麼會有前四?應該是魔術才對吧?28F 01/14 13:22
→ : 年代強度先不管,獎項數量魔術勝出欸
→ : 年代強度先不管,獎項數量魔術勝出欸
推 : Karl Malone應該要選MJ才對啊,MJ的強他最親身體驗30F 01/14 13:23
→ : 馬龍不可能選喬丹啦,對他恨之入骨欸31F 01/14 13:24
推 : 怎麼可能會有老大 弱弱的反串32F 01/14 13:26
推 : 很明顯有些人的選擇不是很客觀33F 01/14 13:30
推 : 完全看出交情的榜XD34F 01/14 13:31
推 : Dr.J 活好久35F 01/14 13:34
推 : 歷史前二就MJ賈霸了36F 01/14 13:36
推 : 馬龍應該覺得裁判給Jordan金身太多 但他選的也夠強37F 01/14 13:43
推 : 怎沒人選LBJ?38F 01/14 13:43
推 : 喇叭現在只有歷史5-7的位子而已39F 01/14 13:44
→ : 第四冠才坐穩前五
→ : 第四冠才坐穩前五
推 : 爵士二老都不想提MJ,人之常情41F 01/14 13:50
推 : 沒人說那些老將 當代亂選嗎? 貴古賤今(90以後)?42F 01/14 13:50
→ : 難怪NBA現在感受到困擾 打到2016 還不請出MJ相救嗎?
→ : 難怪NBA現在感受到困擾 打到2016 還不請出MJ相救嗎?
推 : ㄧ些老人連Jordan 都不選了怎可能輪的到LBJ跟Kobe44F 01/14 13:55
推 : 有些明顯很不客觀45F 01/14 13:57
推 : 再過個十年 應該一堆人選LBJ了46F 01/14 13:58
推 : 這本來就是主觀的選擇47F 01/14 13:58
推 : 爵士二老選MJ那也太M了 不選正常48F 01/14 14:02
推 : 腿迷當道 幻想的人也自然很多49F 01/14 14:06
推 : 怎沒kobe50F 01/14 14:20
--
※ 看板: Z_sports 文章推薦值: 0 目前人氣: 0 累積人氣: 61
回列表(←)
分享